Can an unpublished ruling of the Constitutional Tribunal be the basis for reopening a case? Citizens should not pay for the dispute surrounding the Tribunal

The issue of unpublished Constitutional Tribunal rulings is crucial for citizens seeking to reopen unfavorable cases. The Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) recently addressed this in a resolution, stating that unpublished rulings do not take effect. Experts argue that this stance does not prevent future inquiries or rulings that could allow case reopening based on unconstitutionality. The lack of publication should not hinder citizens' rights to seek legal remedies, especially when unconstitutional norms have caused them harm. The ongoing debate emphasizes the need for a resolution that protects constitutional rights and ensures accountability from the state regarding its legal obligations.